The following excerpt is taken from Chapter
11
of Life on Wheels: For the Active Wheelchair User, by Gary Karp,
copyright 1999, published by O'Reilly & Associates, Inc.
To order, or get more information about Gary's book, call
(800) 998-9938. Permission is granted to print and
distribute this excerpt for noncommercial use as long
as the above source is included. The information in this
article is meant to educate and should not be used as an
alternative for professional medical care.
Vast numbers of people with disabilities remain unemployed. The 1998 NOD/Harris
Survey found a substantial gap in employment for those with disabilities:
Employment continues to be the area with the widest gulf between those who are
disabled and those who are not. Only three in ten working-age adults with
disabilities are employed full or part-time, compared to eight in ten
nondisabled adults. Working-age adults with disabilities are no more likely to
be employed today than they were a decade ago, even though almost three out of
four who are not working say that they would prefer to be working. This low rate
of employment has, in turn, led to an income gap that has not narrowed at all
since 1986, with one in three disabled adults, compared to just one in eight
nondisabled Americans, living in very low income households with less than
$15,000 in annual income.1
Some can't work or find work because of physical issues such as pain,
spasticity, limited energy, or communication difficulties. Unfortunately, there
also appears to be some discrimination on the part of employers, overt or not.
Journalist John Hockenberry--a wheelchair user--produced an investigative report
shown in 1997 on Dateline NBC. He sent two young men to various
employers asking for work. One was quadriplegic, the other walked. The
résumé of the chair rider was intentionally slightly better than
the other decoy. Witnessed by hidden cameras, several potential employers used
tactics to discourage the man with the disability. In one case, he was told
there were no application forms, although forms were produced for the walking
applicant. In another case, the able-bodied man was invited into a preliminary
training session not offered to the chair rider.
These prospective employers might have doubted the ability of the chair rider
to perform the job, but they are at least guilty of pre-judgment without taking
the time to ask how the applicant would adapt to the tasks of the job. In most
cases, resistance is not a matter of hateful prejudice, but of simple ignorance.
When you apply for a job, try to know something ahead of time about the tasks
involved, and be prepared to explain how you will perform them. You could also
point a potential employer to resources such as the Job Accommodation Network,
described below.
There are some tax incentives for employers who spend money on accommodations
for disabled employees. The Disabled Access Credit (IRS Section 44) allows
companies with gross receipts under one million dollars or with fewer than
thirty full-time employees to take a tax credit of 50 percent of their
expenditures for access, up to $5,000 a year. The Architectural and
Transportation Barrier Removal Deduction (IRS Section 190) can be as large as
$15,000, although it was reduced from $35,000 in 1990. You might improve your
chances if you arrive at your job interview equipped with this information.
One of the greatest challenges to the ability to work is the current
structure of the benefits system. Social Security disability benefits, for
instance, are tied to a person's income--and you are not allowed to make very
much without risking the end of your checks or the loss of health and assistance
coverage under Medicare. Similar income limits apply to state-administered
programs like Medicaid (MediCal in California) which serve people with low
incomes. Some people with the skills and desire simply cannot afford to work.
Changes are being proposed to reform Social Security to increase incentives for
people with disabilities to work.
People with disabilities are working more these days, even in the face of
considerable physical limitations. More options are possible than either a
person with a disability or an employer might imagine. More people will get the
chance to demonstrate what is possible, as more workers with disabilities appear
in the workplace. Some progressive programs sponsored by rehab facilities,
universities, independent living programs, or large employers are designed to
promote hiring of disabled workers, so they also make more opportunities
available.
The President's Committee on Employment of People with Disabilities (PCEPD)
was formed by President John Kennedy in the early 1960s to assist the business
community in hiring people with disabilities.
Each year the committee holds a conference which attracts people around the
country, from both government and the private sector. Seminars and lectures at
the conference help corporate executives, human resources specialists,
disability advocates, union representatives, and other interested parties in
promoting employment of people with disabilities.
PCEPD helps employers assess whether someone is capable of performing a job.
Job analysis materials help them determine employment issues such as:
- What functions are essential to the job
- What physical tasks--climbing, kneeling, lifting, carrying, etc.--are
necessary
- How the job would be altered if certain physical requirements were removed
or changed
- What movements through the office or field site are necessary
- What social conditions and interaction with colleagues are required
- What general skills are necessary for the job
- How previous experience might be substituted for lack of specific training
or education
- What equipment, spatial arrangement, or job redesign measures can
accommodate a person's ability to perform the job
Employers are sometimes hard-pressed to imagine how a person with a
disability could perform a given task, but this is often because they don't know
how people adapt. PCEPD helps overcome employers' resistance by demonstrating
how the job can be performed, what adaptations the employer can make, and the
benefits of hiring people with disabilities who are often among the most loyal
of employees.
PCEPD is active on the political front. In March of 1998, President Clinton
established a task force whose mission is to bring levels of employment for
people with disabilities up to par with the general population. Tony Coelho,
chairman of the President's Committee, is optimistic about the task force,
despite the current poor state of employment for people with disabilities.
Only 26 percent of working age people with severe disabilities are
employed--contrast that with the 82 percent employment rate of the general adult
population. The employment figures for individuals with severe disabilities who
are also members of racial or ethnic minority groups is even worse!
Yet I for one am confident that we are going to see real progress in increasing
the employment rate of Americans with disabilities.
By the time the Task Force presents its final report to the President on July
26, 2002--the tenth anniversary of the initial implementation of the employment
provisions of the ADA--we are going to be able to point with pride to higher
employment rates for people with disabilities.2
A service of the PCEPD, the Job Accommodation Network (JAN) provides
information to employers to help them hire and accommodate special needs of
employees with disabilities. An employer can call an 800 number to take
advantage of resources, including:
- Information on adapting a job for a person with a disability
- Information on accommodating an employee with minimal expense
- Support for mobility, sensory, and neurological disabilities
- Access to a large library of material about strategies and products
- Services in English, Spanish, and French
The JAN tells employers that hiring people with disabilities expands the pool
of qualified employees, and that learning how to accommodate disability reduces
Workers' Compensation and other insurance costs. The JAN stresses that
accommodations do not cost what employers generally expect--88 percent of
accommodations suggested by JAN cost less than $1,000.
Technology is creating new opportunities for working with a disability.
People can work in offices or at home with a modem, voice-activated computer,
and speaker phone. Adaptive technology will continue to give entry points to
employment for people with disabilities.
An encouraging note was reported by economists Douglas Kruse and Alan
Krueger. They found that people with spinal cord injuries with sufficient
computer skills were able to earn the same level of income as an able-bodied
worker. The disability was completely transparent where pay was
concerned--unlike the overall population of people with disabilities who earn
less for the same work than the general population. The study reports:
Current computer use at work appears to significantly enhance the earnings power
of people with SCIs and of the general population, even after controlling for
the effects of education, experience, job seniority, union status, gender, and
race. Indeed, SCI workers who use a computer at work earn essentially the same
amount per week as non-SCI workers, while among non-users of computers the pay
of SCI workers is lower than that of non-SCI workers. Those with SCIs who use a
computer at work tend to work substantially more hours per week, and are more
likely to hold full-time jobs than are SCI workers who do not work with
computers.3
There is a tremendous need for people with computer and technology skills.
Jobs in programming, data analysis, or database administration are waiting for
qualified candidates. The situation is severe enough that in 1998 one of the top
news stories in California's Silicon Valley was about the desire of the computer
industry to allow more immigration of people with these skills because of the
industry's claim that there are not enough qualified candidates in the U.S.
At the May 1998 national conference of the President's Committee, chairman
Tony Coelho made these comments in his opening speech:
Right now, more than 346,000 computer-programmer and systems-analyst jobs are
vacant in U.S. companies with more than 100 employees. These jobs pay well.
Computer science graduates are receiving job offers averaging over $40,000 a
year!
A positive result of the labor shortage is that barriers of discrimination are
beginning to fall. Businesses of all sizes are looking at people with
disabilities to fill their needs. This burgeoning demand creates an enormous
opportunity for people with disabilities who have the skills and experience
employers seek.4
The study by Kruse and Krueger found that people with quadriplegia, college
graduates, and younger people were more likely to use a computer, and this
correlated to higher levels of employment. Companies did not have to invest in
training people or risk hiring someone without proven skills. Other findings
include:5
- Only 17 percent of spinal cord injured workers returned to their previous
job following injury.
- Another 10 percent said they could have returned to their previous work if
they had been provided training and adaptive devices.
- Pay per hour was only slightly lower for people re-employed after injury,
but hours--and weekly pay--fell by 25 percent.
- 51 percent of people in white collar jobs returned to work.
- 32 percent of people in blue collar jobs returned to work.
Larger corporations tend to be more willing to invest in hiring people with
disabilities and in the equipment they need. They have the resources to commit
to searching for people, sending staff to conferences such as those put on by
PCEPD, and supporting accommodation needs of an employee. Ultimately, these
efforts are worth the investment.
Technology has made it easier to operate a business from home. A computer
with a modem, a telephone, and a fax machine put you in contact with the
world--including clients.
The U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) helps some people seeking
financing for a small business startup. They don't make direct loans, but if
your bank turns you down, you might qualify for an SBA loan guarantee under the
Handicapped Assistance Loan (HAL) program. If your application is accepted, SBA
essentially promises to pay the bank if you default on the loan, removing the
bank's risk. The SBA puts certain limits on the interest the bank may charge and
also restricts the type of business they will approve. Gambling or real estate
investment, for instance, are excluded from its list of approved businesses.
The SBA also provides information to help you start your business. Local
offices provide advisers through the Service Corps of Retired Executives (SCORE)
program, in which retired business executives review your plans and consult with
you to help ensure success.
The workplace has witnessed an extraordinary shift toward contract and
part-time workers. Corporations want to reduce full-time staff in order to save
fixed overhead expenses of wages and benefits. More work projects are of shorter
duration, with rapidly changing marketplaces and technologies. It can be
difficult to predict what skills a company will need at any one time. Part-time
and contract workers give companies flexibility.
Manpower Incorporated is an example of a temporary employment agency which
has grown to be one of the largest corporations in the world. It maintains a
list of people with specific skills and refers them to companies who call
looking for those skills. Wages are paid by Manpower, who is paid a fee by the
employer. Temporary job referrals can result in full-time jobs, since some
companies see the service as a way of getting to know a potential employee
without having to make a commitment to hire them full-time from the start.
Many people question the impact of part-time and contract work on employees
and communities. Workers can wonder where the next job will come from, not earn
as much as they need, or lose security by not having health or retirement
benefits. However, many people like being a contract worker. You get to work on
a variety of projects, meet more people, and gain a variety of skills. You also
get to experience the employer before making a full-time commitment, if that is
an option. If you can perform some work at home, you might be able to gain a tax
benefit from deducting the costs of a home office. The flexibility of contract
work can be a good employment solution for a person with a disability.
Some companies are experimenting with flex-time, in which jobs are shared
and--to the degree possible--people set their own hours. This--along with
part-time contract opportunities--opens up possibilities for people who have
trouble committing to a full-time job because they are unable to predict
physical problems such as severe infections, pressure sores, or exacerbations of
MS, for instance.
Title I of the Americans with Disabilities Act requires equal opportunity for
people with disabilities, affecting all employers in the private sector with
fifteen or more employees, as of July 26, 1994. The ADA protects you from being
discriminated against for employment solely based on your disability. It does
not guarantee you a job. You still have to qualify based on your abilities.
Federal agencies and any business receiving federal contracts of $10,000 or
more were already held from discriminating based on disability by the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Sections 501 and 503 called on the government and
its contractors to take affirmative action to hire people with disabilities.
The Vietnam Veterans Readjustment Assistance Act of 1974 similarly requires
government contractors to take affirmative action on behalf of covered
veterans.
Many people with disabilities are not employed, but still have time and
skills to contribute. There are satisfying and productive options available.
There is plenty of work to do to advance the opportunities--or remove the
barriers--for people with disabilities. There is no shortage of groups and
associations who need help with advocacy. You can volunteer time at your local
Independent Living Center or a disability-specific group like United Cerebral
Palsy to advance the inclusion of people with disabilities in our culture.
American Disabled for Attendant Programs Today (ADAPT) is probably the most
radical of disability advocacy groups. It has taken militant action in order to
achieve access to transportation and personal assistance services in the
community rather than nursing homes. There are local chapters of ADAPT in many
cities around the country.
You can volunteer time and experience to a local rehabilitation hospital,
which typically welcome people in a peer support role for people facing a new
disability. You might be surprised how much you have to offer from your own
experience.
There are always issues of importance to the disability community which
require people to express support or concerns about pending legislation of
public policies. Organizations such as ADAPT or Justin and Yoshiko Dart's
Justice for All regularly notify people about such activities, as do politically
oriented publications such as The Ragged Edge or Mouth. You
can contribute with letters or phone calls to representatives, business, or
civic leaders expressing your position on disability issues.
There are many other volunteer options to choose from. Visits to a local
elementary school are often welcome by teachers, either to support their
programs or as a way of offering children positive models of people with
disabilities. Many libraries are looking for tutors to help teach adult reading
courses. Local churches or agencies need help in serving many people in need,
such as those who are homeless. Especially if you are feeling frustrated with
your life, devoting time to your community is a wonderful way to forget your own
problems and gain meaning and gratification.
The fact is that no one has the right to tell you that you can't work because
of your disability. If you have the motivation, a desire to learn and develop a
profession or skill, and some notion of how you would adapt your disability to
that work, then go do it. Even people who should know better--like rehab
staff--might discourage you for fear that you are hoping for too much. But the
case has been made many times over. People with disabilities of all sorts are
working as doctors, lawyers, activists, writers, publishers, artists, musicians,
inventors, business owners, athletes, and almost any other pursuit you can
imagine. If you want to work, then get out there and find out on your own terms
what it takes.
- Risher, The 1998 N.O.D./Harris Survey of Americans with Disabilities.
- Tony Coelho, chairman, opening remarks, President's Committee on Employment of People with
Disabilities 51st Annual Conference.
- Douglas Kruse and Alan Krueger, Disability, Employment, and Earnings in
the Dawn of the Computer Age--Executive Summary, Bureau of Economic
Research, Rutgers University, October 1995.
- Tony Coelho's opening remarks.
- Kruse, Disability, Employment, and Earnings.